A Borrowed Name, a Sham Marriage and a Korean Passport: The Case That Took 25 Years

Criminal DefenseNationality and passports

A woman gained Korean nationality through a sham marriage under a borrowed name in 1997. Decades later, showing that passport at the airport became a crime.

Quick answer: In Korea, a marriage registered without a real intention to live as spouses can be legally ineffective for nationality purposes. In this real case, Korea’s Supreme Court held that a woman who married on paper never acquired Korean nationality, so using the Korean passport issued in that identity was a crime.

Key points

  • Nationality through marriage required a real agreement to marry, not just a registration.
  • Without that agreement, the nationality was never acquired, and the passport recorded false facts.
  • Two courts acquitted. The Supreme Court reversed, and she was convicted on remand.
  • Time alone did not cure the problem.

The case

A borrowed name and a marriage on paperA real case decided by a Korean courtReal case

In 1997 a Chinese woman of Korean ethnicity wanted to move to Korea. She paid a neighbour for the use of the neighbour’s identity and, through a broker, paid a Korean man 3 million won to marry her on paper. Under the nationality law of the time, a foreign woman who became the wife of a Korean man acquired Korean nationality, and she did so under the neighbour’s name.

She lived in Korea for decades, had a passport reissued in that name, and used it six times at Incheon Airport.

What it meansThe problem began in 1997 and surfaced decades later.

Two courts said not guilty

Prosecuted for using a passport containing false information, obstructing immigration officers by deception and passport offences, she was acquitted at trial. The court reasoned that once she had acquired Korean nationality, using the passport issued in that identity was not a crime, or intent was hard to prove. The first appeal court agreed.

The Supreme Court disagreed

Becoming “the wife of a Korean national” required a real agreement to marry, meaning an intention to form a genuine marital relationship. A marriage registered only as a way to enter or work in Korea was not enough. Without that agreement she never acquired Korean nationality, so the passport recorded false facts, and presenting it at the airport deceived the immigration officers.

On remand the appeal court convicted her and imposed six months’ imprisonment, suspended for one year, taking into account that she had lived in Korea for a long time without any criminal record.

Why this matters

  • Status built on a marriage without a real intention to live as spouses can fall away, however long ago it was registered.
  • Ordinary later acts, like showing a passport, can then become crimes.
  • If an old marriage or document may be questioned, get confidential advice before you deal with immigration or renew a document.

How to apply this to your situation

If your situation is thisWhat the case suggests you do
Your status came through a marriage that was not genuineGet confidential advice before you deal with immigration.
Someone suggests marrying on paper for a visaDo not. It can undo your status and lead to crimes years later.
You are living under an identity that is not your ownEach use of that identity, such as a passport, can be a new offence. Get advice.
Immigration investigators contact youTalk to a lawyer before you give a statement.

When a lawyer becomes useful

We advise foreign nationals on immigration investigations and the criminal cases that can follow them, in English and in confidence.

Soobin You
Soobin YouFounding Attorney, YUSU LawfirmFormer prosecutor. Sets the strategy for criminal and immigration related cases.Profile →
Kyungmin Kim
Kyungmin KimDeputy Managing AttorneyEducated in the United States. Advises on administrative and immigration questions in English.Profile →

This article describes a real Korean court decision for general information. It is not legal advice, and the outcome of any case depends on its own facts. Statutory provisions are subject to amendment.

Related guides

Immigration

Questions about an old marriage, visa or document?

In a first consultation we look at:

  • the immigration and criminal risks in your situation
  • what to do before contacting immigration
  • how investigations usually proceed

A consultation is not a commitment. If you need representation, we explain what it would involve and what it would cost before you decide.

How consultations work. Asking us on WhatsApp is free. A 30 minute consultation with a lawyer, in English, in person or by Zoom: KRW 100,000 (VAT included), the same rate as our Korean clients, or USD 85 by PayPal from abroad, which includes international payment costs. If you instruct us, the consultation fee is credited toward your legal fee.

Please do not send documents or evidence through the form. We arrange a secure channel once we take the matter on.
Scroll to Top