Hospital director: not charged for a staff violation. YUSU Lawfirm case result

Hospital Director Investigated Under the Medical Service Act: Not Charged

A violation of the Medical Service Act happened inside a clinic. The person who did it was investigated, and so was the head of the clinic, under the rule that makes an employer liable for staff offences. This is a case in which the head of the clinic was not charged.

In short: The head of a medical institution was investigated under the joint penalty provision of the Medical Service Act for a violation committed in the course of the institution’s work. We reviewed how the institution supervised its staff and argued the legal limits of that liability. The prosecutor suspended the indictment.

MatterMedical Service Act violation within a medical institution; liability of the head of the institution
IssuesThe joint penalty provision, whether reasonable care and supervision were exercised
StageInvestigation
ResultIndictment suspended by the prosecutor
Notice of the prosecutor's decision to suspend indictment for a hospital director under the Medical Service Act, details redacted
The prosecutor’s decision. Names, case number, office and dates are redacted.

What was at stake

Article 91 of the Medical Service Act is a joint penalty provision. When an employee or agent commits certain violations in the course of the business, the employer can be fined as well as the person who acted. But the employer is not punished if it did not neglect reasonable care and supervision to prevent the violation.

So the case did not turn on whether the violation happened. It turned on what the head of the institution had done, in practice, to prevent it.

The strategy

The strategy in this case

  1. Document the supervision system. We reviewed how the institution was run: rules, training, checks and who was responsible for what.
  2. Argue the proviso, not just mitigation. We set out the legal requirements of the joint penalty provision and why reasonable care and supervision had been exercised.
  3. Put it in writing before the decision. The argument went to the prosecutor in a defense opinion while the charging decision was still open.

For an employer, the strongest defense is often the paper trail of how the workplace was run before anything went wrong.

Clinic or hospital under investigation?

Tell us what the alleged violation is, who carried it out, and whether you have been summoned. The supervision record is usually the key evidence.

Send 3 lines on WhatsApp or use the short form

When to call a medical law lawyer in Korea

When an inspection or a complaint suggests a violation by staff, and before anyone from the institution gives a statement. A medical law lawyer in Korea can gather the supervision records, prepare the head of the institution for questioning, and argue the joint penalty proviso in writing. Foreign medical professionals working in Korea can also ask a medical law lawyer in Korea how a case may affect their licence or visa.

Soobin You
Soobin YouFounding Attorney, YUSU LawfirmFormer prosecutor and founding attorney. Handled this case and wrote the defense submissions.Profile →
Kyungmin Kim
Kyungmin KimDeputy Managing AttorneyEducated in the United States. Works with English-speaking clients directly, including at police interviews.Profile →

Why clients choose YUSU Lawfirm as their medical law lawyer in Korea

  • We read the joint penalty provision the way a prosecutor does. We know what evidence of supervision persuades, and we file it before the decision.
  • A Korean law firm run by a former prosecutor. Attorney Soobin You served as a public prosecutor. She sets the strategy and reviews every written submission herself.
  • English without a middle layer. Attorney Soobin You and Attorney Kyungmin Kim work with clients directly in English.
  • Early, before the decision is made. Most of our results come from submissions filed before the prosecutor decides whether to charge.
  • Seoul, Gyeongju or Zoom. Consultations in person or by video, wherever you are.

Frequently asked questions

Can a hospital director be punished for what staff did?

Yes, under joint penalty provisions, unless the director did not neglect reasonable care and supervision.

What counts as reasonable supervision?

It depends on the institution, but rules, training, checks and how they were enforced in practice are all relevant.

Is a suspended indictment a criminal record?

It is not a conviction, though it remains in the investigation record.

This case has been anonymised. Names, dates, places and the authorities involved are not disclosed. Every case turns on its own facts, and a past result does not guarantee a similar outcome. This page is general information, not legal advice.

Related guides

Medical law

Investigated over something staff did?

Three lines are enough to start: what happened, what stage the case is at, and your visa type if you are not Korean. In reply we tell you:

  • whether the joint penalty proviso can apply to you
  • which supervision records to gather now
  • how to prepare for questioning

A first message is not a commitment. If you need representation, we tell you what it involves and the fee before you decide.

Consultations in English, in person in Seoul (Mapo) or Gyeongju, or by Zoom. Please do not send documents through the form.
Scroll to Top