Can a Truthful Online Review Be Criminal Defamation in Korea?

In many countries, telling the truth is a complete answer to a defamation claim. In Korea it is not. Posting a true but damaging statement online can be a crime, and businesses do file criminal complaints over customer reviews. The good news for reviewers is that Korean courts have repeatedly acquitted people whose reviews were honest and written to inform other customers.

Quick answer: Yes, a truthful statement can be criminal defamation in Korea. Online, it is an offence only if it was made “with intent to defame” (비방할 목적) under Article 70(1) of the Network Act, punishable by up to 3 years in prison or a fine of up to KRW 30 million. Courts treat intent to defame and serving the public interest as opposites: if your main purpose was to inform other consumers, intent to defame is generally denied, even if you were also angry. The Supreme Court acquitted a mother who posted an honest review of a postnatal care center on this basis.

Key points

  • Korea criminalizes defamation by stating facts, true or false. False statements are punished more heavily.
  • Online, a true statement is criminal only with intent to defame. Consumer information is treated as a public interest purpose.
  • A secondary personal motive does not create intent to defame if your main purpose was to inform others.
  • Reviews with insults, threats to keep posting or demands for compensation have been convicted.
  • Under the Network Act, a truthful defamation charge cannot proceed against the victim’s clearly expressed wishes.

The Korean rules in one table

ProvisionWhat it coversMaximum penalty
Criminal Act, Art. 307(1)Publicly stating facts that damage someone’s reputation, true or not2 years or KRW 5 million
Criminal Act, Art. 307(2)Publicly stating false facts, knowing they are false5 years, 10 years suspension of qualifications, or KRW 10 million
Criminal Act, Art. 310No punishment under Art. 307(1) if the statement is true and solely in the public interestDefense
Network Act, Art. 70(1)Stating facts online with intent to defame3 years or KRW 30 million
Network Act, Art. 70(2)Stating false facts online with intent to defame7 years, 10 years suspension, or KRW 50 million

The truth and public interest defense in Article 310 applies only to Article 307(1). It does not apply to the online offence in Article 70(1). Online, the battle is fought over intent to defame. If intent to defame is denied, the court then considers ordinary defamation under Article 307(1), where the Article 310 defense is available.

What “intent to defame” means

Intent to defame is a purpose to harm the person’s reputation, beyond simply knowing the statement could lower it. The Constitutional Court upheld the online offence in 2023 by a narrow majority, emphasizing that this purpose requirement limits it. Courts decide intent by looking at:

  • the content and nature of the facts stated
  • who the statement reached
  • how it was expressed, including tone and wording
  • how much damage it did or could do
  • your main motive

Public interest includes the interests of a particular group, such as consumers of a service. Where the main purpose was public interest, intent to defame is denied even if there was also a personal motive.

How courts have treated consumer reviews

ReviewOutcomeWhy
Postnatal care center: a mother’s blog and forum review of problems she experiencedAcquitted (Supreme Court)Information for other expectant mothers; consumer rights to information carry weight
Hair salon: damaged hair and rude service, posted on social media in a measured toneAcquittedBased on real experience, mainly accurate, moderate wording
Hair salon: refusal of a booking and an argumentAcquitted, upheld on appealFact based, aimed at sharing information
Study room: poor facilities, posted in an exam candidates’ forumAcquittedInformation for other candidates, no demand for compensation
Lodging: bedbug bitesAcquittedReasonable basis for the claim, purpose of warning other travelers
Guesthouse: insults about the owner and a promise to post the review every weekConvicted, fine of KRW 300,000Wording and messages showed a purpose to retaliate

Writing a review that stays on the right side of the line

  • Describe what happened, with dates and specifics, rather than conclusions about the person.
  • Keep the tone measured. Insults can be a separate offence and are strong evidence of intent to defame.
  • Post where consumers look for information, not on the business owner’s personal pages.
  • Do not link the review to demands for refunds or compensation.
  • Keep your evidence: receipts, photos, messages, medical records.

If a business files a complaint against you

You will usually be called for a police interview. The questions will focus on whether what you wrote was true and why you wrote it. Prepare a clear account of your experience and your purpose, with evidence. Because a truthful online defamation charge cannot proceed against the victim’s clearly expressed wishes, a settlement can also end that charge, but you do not need to settle a case you can win.

When to call a defamation lawyer in Korea

A defamation lawyer in Korea is worth calling as soon as you receive a police summons over a review or post, and before you delete or edit anything. A defamation lawyer in Korea can assess whether the statement is fact or opinion, whether it is provable, and how to present your purpose. If you are the person being attacked online, a defamation lawyer in Korea can also advise on a complaint of your own.

Soobin You
Soobin YouFounding Attorney, YUSU LawfirmFormer prosecutor. Assesses how a prosecutor will read the post and your purpose.Profile →
Kyungmin Kim
Kyungmin KimDeputy Managing AttorneyEducated in the United States. Handles the case with you in English and translates the posts accurately.Profile →

Why foreigners choose YUSU Lawfirm as their defamation lawyer in Korea

  • Context made visible. We assemble the evidence that shows why you wrote what you wrote, which is where these cases are decided.
  • English without a middle layer. Attorney Soobin You and Attorney Kyungmin Kim both work with clients directly in English, so nothing important is lost between you and your lawyer.
  • A former prosecutor reviews your file. Our founding attorney served as a public prosecutor. She reviews every case herself, sets the strategy and reviews and revises every written submission.
  • Police interviews attended in English. Attorney Kyungmin Kim, educated in the United States, attends interviews with English-speaking clients.
  • Seoul and Gyeongju offices, plus Zoom. Consultations in person or by video, wherever you are in Korea.

Frequently asked questions

Is a bad Google review illegal in Korea?

An honest, fact based review written to inform other customers has repeatedly been held not to involve intent to defame. Insulting or retaliatory reviews carry real risk.

Is it defamation if I name the business but not a person?

Businesses and their owners can both be victims of defamation. The analysis of truth and purpose is the same.

Should I delete my review after a complaint?

Get advice first. Deleting does not undo a completed offence, and the original wording may matter for your defense.

Can I be sued civilly as well?

Yes. Civil damages claims are separate from the criminal case.

This article is general information about Korean law, based on statutes and published Korean court decisions. It is not legal advice. Each case depends on its own facts, and statutory provisions are subject to amendment.

Related guides

Defamation

Received a police summons over an online review or post?

Tell us what you posted, where, and who complained. In reply we tell you:

  • how the post is likely to be assessed
  • what evidence to gather now
  • whether settlement is worth considering

A first message is not a commitment. If you need representation, we tell you what it would involve and what it would cost before you decide.

How consultations work. Asking us on WhatsApp is free. A 30 minute consultation with a lawyer, in English, in person or by Zoom: KRW 100,000 (VAT included), the same rate as our Korean clients, or USD 85 by PayPal from abroad, which includes international payment costs. If you instruct us, the consultation fee is credited toward your legal fee.

Please do not send documents or evidence through the form. We arrange a secure channel once we take the matter on.
Scroll to Top