At the end of a Korean criminal trial, the prosecutor stands up and asks for a specific sentence: two years in prison, a fine of ten million won. Foreign defendants, and their families watching, often assume that is the sentence. It is not. It is the prosecutor’s opinion, and the judge is free to go below it, or above it.
Quick answer: No. The prosecutor’s sentence request (구형) is an opinion on sentencing given under Article 302 of the Criminal Procedure Act after the evidence is heard. The Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court have long held that it does not bind the court. The judge decides the sentence, usually at a later hearing, and can impose less, the same, or more than the prosecutor asked for, and can add penalties the prosecutor did not request. What happens between the request and the judgment, including your final statement and any settlement or sentencing materials, can still change the result.
Key points
- The request comes at the end of the evidence stage, followed by the defense’s closing argument and your final statement.
- It is advocacy, not a decision. Courts may sentence above or below it.
- Courts have imposed a fine the prosecutor did not ask for, and ordered programs the prosecutor did not request, without breaching any rule.
- A prosecutor who makes no request at all does not invalidate the trial, as long as the court gave the opportunity.
- The prosecutor also cannot appeal to the Supreme Court only because an appellate sentence was too light.
What the sentence request is
Article 302 of the Criminal Procedure Act requires the prosecutor, once the examination of the defendant and the evidence is finished, to state an opinion on the facts and the application of the law. The part about the penalty is called the sentence request. It is a form of argument, the prosecution’s view of the right sentence.
The Constitutional Court has described it as an opinion on sentencing that does not bind the court and does not, by itself, have any legal effect on the defendant.
What the court can do
| Situation | Has the court acted lawfully? |
|---|---|
| Sentence heavier than the prosecutor requested | Yes |
| Adding a fine the prosecutor did not request | Yes |
| Ordering a treatment or education program the prosecutor did not request | Yes |
| Same sentence for co-defendants who received different requests | Yes |
| Prosecutor did not make a request at all | The trial is still valid if the opportunity was given |
The same principle applies to the legal provisions listed in the indictment. They help define the case and the defense, but the interpretation and application of the law belong to the court.
Written sentence requests
Sentence requests should in principle be made orally in open court. In 2026 the Supreme Court held that a prosecutor stating the sentencing opinion in writing after the hearing closed was undesirable, but not by itself grounds to overturn the judgment, unless it seriously undermined the defendant’s final statement or the right to a defense.
What still matters after the request
- The defense closing argument: the defense answers the request with the facts, the law and the sentencing factors.
- Your final statement: a short, sincere statement in your own words. An interpreter will translate it; prepare it in advance.
- Settlement and deposits: agreements with the victim, or deposits where the victim will not settle, can still be submitted before judgment.
- Sentencing documents: letters, proof of circumstances, and for foreigners, what a sentence would mean for your stay in Korea.
As a former prosecutor, Attorney Soobin You has made sentence requests herself. A request reflects the charge, the record and office practice at the time. The court looks at the whole case, including what happens after the request. That gap is where the defense works.
When to call a criminal trial lawyer in Korea
Ideally before the trial starts, but it is not too late after the request. A criminal trial lawyer in Korea can use the time before judgment to file sentencing materials, approach the victim properly and prepare your final statement. If the judgment is too heavy, a criminal trial lawyer in Korea can advise on an appeal within the deadline.


Why foreigners choose YUSU Lawfirm as their criminal trial lawyer in Korea
- Every hearing explained in advance. We tell you what will happen in the courtroom, in English, so nothing on the day comes as a surprise.
- English without a middle layer. Attorney Soobin You and Attorney Kyungmin Kim both work with clients directly in English, so nothing important is lost between you and your lawyer.
- A former prosecutor reviews your file. Our founding attorney served as a public prosecutor. She reviews every case herself, sets the strategy and reviews and revises every written submission.
- Police interviews attended in English. Attorney Kyungmin Kim, educated in the United States, attends interviews with English-speaking clients.
- Seoul and Gyeongju offices, plus Zoom. Consultations in person or by video, wherever you are in Korea.
Frequently asked questions
When is the sentence actually decided?
Usually at a separate sentencing hearing a few weeks after the closing hearing. The judge announces the sentence in court.
Can the judge give me a heavier sentence than the prosecutor asked for?
Yes. It is uncommon, but the request does not limit the court.
Should I speak in my final statement?
Usually yes, briefly and sincerely. Prepare it with your lawyer so it is accurate and translated well.
What if I disagree with the judgment?
You can appeal within the deadline. See our guide to criminal appeals in Korea.
This article is general information about Korean law, based on statutes and published Korean court decisions. It is not legal advice. Each case depends on its own facts, and statutory provisions are subject to amendment.
Related guides
Criminal trials
The prosecutor has asked for a sentence in your Korean case?
Tell us the charge, the request and the date of the sentencing hearing. In reply we tell you:
- what can still be filed before judgment
- how to prepare your final statement
- what the likely outcome means for your visa
A first message is not a commitment. If you need representation, we tell you what it would involve and what it would cost before you decide.
How consultations work. Asking us on WhatsApp is free. A 30 minute consultation with a lawyer, in English, in person or by Zoom: KRW 100,000 (VAT included), the same rate as our Korean clients, or USD 85 by PayPal from abroad, which includes international payment costs. If you instruct us, the consultation fee is credited toward your legal fee.
Please do not send documents or evidence through the form. We arrange a secure channel once we take the matter on.